Insurance agencies in Payne, Ohio, the US. Insurance agencies locations in Payne, Ohio. Find the nearest insurance agencies locations, near you. All types of business services Accounting ATM Bank Finance Insurance School All insurance agencies in Payne Waters Shafer & Clark Insurance Insurance agency +1 419-263-2127 106 North Main Street, Payne, Ohio 45880 Write a review Phone Directions Williamson Insurance Insurance agency +1 419-263-0168 101 East Merrin Street, Payne, Ohio 45880 Write a review Phone Website Directions